Great White North Prognostications

I think this comes down to what people use their device for. For typing text primarily for emails the various blackberry RIM devices win hands down.  Most people that I know who have a RIM device only use it for the two features of email and as a very oddly shaped phone; nothing else. I have only met one person who used the web feature which I suspect is the only other feature that a few people use on their blackberrys.

But the iPhone seems to be missing the keyboard which is simply the best way to enter text so that somewhat excludes the email responding crowd. But the key feature of the iPhone other than a repository of cool is its web browser. The screen is as big as is possible on a reasonably sized pocket device. Plus the browser basically works. I create websites that are quite demanding of the web browser and they basically work on the iPhone. No other portable web device that I have experienced can display the web usably. Most phone browsers mutilate most websites and most websites are not designed to work on phones. Technologies like WAP and such are mostly complete failures. But the iPhone truly brings the power of the internet to your hands in a portable way. But this power is limited to the informational part. The social and communications part is lacking. The RIM gets some of the communications part but not the informational and misses some of the social.

So where will this lead these two companies sales? I think that any head to head comparisons are meaningless for the most part at this time. If you are one of those people who is now effectively on call 24/7 because they are so reachable via their blackberry then the iPhone while probably good for your sanity just doesn’t have the email features that you need.  So at this time RIM need not worry about losing those legions of lawyers and MBAs with their crackberry monkeys. But where iPhone will do well is by getting those people who want more out of their phones and want the wonderful data features and the various gizmo features such as GPS, camera, watching movies, and so on. These are the people who bought the razr and thought that they were getting something newer and better. iPhone will cream off some of the top executives from RIM in that they will want something cooler than their worker drones. So with all this in mind it looks like RIM will continue to grow will little loss to iPhone but iPhone will be growing its market from people who either are looking for something new and better or just want to be the coolest kid on the block.

One twist is that the iPhone is both releasing a 3G version and expanding into Europe and Canada. This will make things like market share, units shipped and so on very hard to compare year to year.

Since there is no shortage of lawyers and MBAs being churned out by universities everywhere then RIM need not worry too much about market share. iPhone does need to worry about regular customers willingness to pay for rather expensive data plans.

With all this in mind RIM is safe and AAPL might be in for a wallstreet let down with the next iPhone.